Comparison of self-reported adherence to cervical and breast cancer screening guidelines in relation to the researcher’s profession.

Maria Moudatsou1,3, George Kritsotakis2, Antonis Koutis1, Athanasios Alegakis4, Evangelia Panagoulopoulou1, Anastasios Philalithis1

1. Department of Social Medicine, Medical School, University of Crete, Heraklion,
2. Department of Nursing, Laboratory of Epidemiology, Prevention & Management of Diseases, Hellenic Meditarranean University, Crete
3. Department of Social work, Hellenic Meditarranean University, Crete
4. Laboratory of Toxicology, Medical School, University of Crete, Heraklion

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Self-reporting is a major and, in many cases, the only feasible method to use in cancer screening research. However, its validity has been questioned and numerous studies indicate that women over-report their participation in preventive Pap-test and mammography screenings.
Aim: The objective of this study was to determine whether individuals report in the same way their Pap-test and mammography screening behaviors when the interviews are conducted by researchers of different professions, in this case a social worker and a general practitioner.

Methods: Two studies assessing adherence to cervical and breast cancer screening guidelines were conducted during late 2006 – early 2007 in the same 114 women in Crete, Greece. Kappa coefficient was used to measure the agreement of participants’ answers to the same questions between the two interviewers.

Results: Only 32 out of 90 (35,5%) of the women replied that ‘have had at least one’ gynecological exam respectively in both studies (Kappa=0.189, p<0.001). Agreement was also weak (Kappa=0.386 and 0.235) for self-reported mammography and Pap smear tests in the last 6 years, respectively. There were no significant differences in major demographic characteristics between women who provided, or not, the same answers in both interviewers, apart from the self-reported health status (p=0.032).

Conclusions: Women overestimated their self-reported adherence to cancer screening guidelines when the interviewer was a doctor once their responses were matched to those given to a social worker. The professional identities of the researchers that perform the data collection should be made explicit to make comparison across studies more accurate.

Keywords: adherence, cancer, gynecological tests, rater’s agreement, self-reported health

Read Also

Alternative and complementary to medication therapies for type 2 Diabetes Mellitus

Maria Efthymia Katsa1, Basiliki Adamopoulou2, Andrea Paola Rojas Gil3

Autism Spectrum Conditions (ASC)-Inclusion: an intervention tool for children with autism spectrum disorders (ASD)

Vasiliki Mougia1, Theodora Antareli2

Looking into the nurses’ views regarding implementation of Evidence-Based Nursing in clinical practice

Efrosini Papadopoulou1, Evridiki Kamba2, Areti Stavropoulou3, Martha Kelesi4

Antibiotics overuse and development of antimicrobial resistance

George Elesnitsalis1, Ioanna Vekili2

Burnout syndrome in the professionals employed in special education schools

Niki Panagouli1, Evangelia Meimeti2, Petros Galanis3, Maria Tsiachri4, Pagona Koutsogianni5, Aris Yfantis6, Ioannis Moisoglou6